So why would thousands of British citizens line up to voluntarily euthanize household pets? Peasants Tell Tales: The Meaning of Mother Goose 2. Website. By looking at how the stories change, Darnton was able to understand how the peasants viewed the changes occurring during their times as well. Robert Darnton. The Great Cat Massacre, Introduction and Chapter 1. It's gruesome, but of special interest for its insight into a typesetting shop of the period. The Great Cat Massacre Although the title of this book strikes the reader as unusual it begins to make complete sense once it is read. And so began a rumor that led to Germany losing World War I. .Without doubt, Hilda Kean has written an original and challenging monograph whose message forces readers to rethink their attitudes about themselves and the animals around them.”, "The many personal, and often moving, reminiscences collected in this book reveal just how many enduring wartime memories, happy or sad, featured an animal. Kean does a thorough job of collecting anecdotes, letters, news clippings that collectively shed light on the many experiences of pet owners, their children, vets, animal rescuers, politicians, and the animals themselves. For example, not only does Darnton tell us that "Little Red Riding Hood" originated among peasants 18th century France, and that the story has a gruesome end (the wolf eats the girl), but he also describes how the peasants suffered under the oppressive seigneurial system, faced with poverty, malnutrition, and exploitation by landowners. Primary themes include: liberalism; national identity and its construction; race; ethnicity; genders and sexualities; (post)colonialism; and the relation between history and everyday life. In the first chapter of "The Great Cat Massacre", Robert Darnton uses old fairy tales passed down through the generations to examine history, rather than just examining the history itself. Seeing as cultural studies most often focuses on the questions of why a society acted as it did, or why certain stories were told, or why a peasant force rebelled when it did, it is easy to connect French fairytales and oral tradition with the study of French culture. For example, as evident in many of the folktales, peasants were masters of trickery and were very clever. I had thought it was a universal silver lining throughout Europe, though Darnton explains that the French peasants didn't get quite as lucky as their peers over the English Channel. The stories he tells, such as those of Mother Goose, are simple and at times familiar stories to modern-day readers. However, ones that were told by the peasants of the village. The second chapter (The Great Cat Massacre) has a unique pretext and continues the "otherness" theme, although it's even more disturbing to modern sensibilities. The narrator of The Great Gatsby is a young man from Minnesota named Nick Carraway. Ruth H. Bloch, The Construction of Gender in a Republican World Books to Borrow. Tom dominates the conversation at dinner; he wishes to … In 1914, a train pulled into a provincial British railway station. Darnton showed that life for peasants was so horrible and serious that even their children’s stories were reflected this lack of innocence and overwhelming turmoil. The Great Cat Massacre: And Other Episodes in French Cultural History. .Kean recovers how animals and humans meaningfully interacted and, in so doing, challenges the ways historians have interpreted the wartime experience. The Master's Mistake Behavioral Biology, History: The pranksters carry out their master plan by killing the Cats and then staging a mock trial. . Darnton uses this to show the similarities and differences in the outlooks of peasants from different countries. The morals were different in the past, and instead of being happy and positive, they were telling children that life isn’t always fair, and that sometimes you will just get unlucky. We all know the classic stories of Mother Goose, but Darnton puts the stories into their original context in order to show their changing meanings, structures, and audience. What makes this cultural history is that Darnton is looking back into a time in certain countries that we will never get to experience. Her book suggests that history should acknowledge ‘everybody’ to include bodies with four legs as well as two.”, “The tremendous loss of human life during World War II has made this episode an unsuitable one to criticize. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for The Great Cat Massacre : And Other Episodes in French Cultural History by Robert Darnton (2009, Trade Paperback) at the best online prices at eBay! April 2012 A friend of Daisy's is also in attendance. If you were curious.) The great cat massacre and other episodes in French cultural history Item Preview remove-circle ... download 1 file . This tragic event in the history of France continues to fascinate American historians and actors today. Animal Behavior, Sociology: For print-disabled users. The Great Cat Massacre Essay 3168 Words | 13 Pages. The Great Cat Massacre Although the title of this book strikes the reader as unusual it begins to make complete sense once it is read. In the case of Mother Goose, these stories were told and retold until they were eventually compiled into what we have come to know as "The Little Red Riding Hood" and other stories. . Even from the story of the little red riding hood we can see the differences in the ways the story was told in the Enlightenment Age compared to how it is told in our culture. THE GREAT CAT MASSACRE – SPREADING THE PLAGUE, 1232. Daisy is Nick's cousin, while Tom was Nick's classmate at Yale. Not only do we find out more about the people int the societies that shared these stories, but historians can also analyze the stories themselves to find out more about the culture. First Edition. Taking the title of Darnton's book a little too far - removing the link to other massacres! It is the idea that we as historians are trying to discover a more abstract view of the peasants. Not to be repetitive of the other comments in the class but chapter 1 of Darnton’s book is a great example of a discursive analysis. Trapped between incompatible sensitivities, the cats had the worst of both worlds. The stories show the peasant opinions on the upper classes, on the country as a whole, and on the value systems currently in place at the time. Workers Revolt: The Great Cat Massacre of the Rue Saint-Severin 3. . I believe this is a strong strategy to study cultural history because by using the actual accounts from peasants living at this time period, one can gain an insight into their minds and what they were thinking and living through. Also includes sites with a short overview, synopsis, book report, or summary of Robert Darnton’s The Great Cat Massacre. Raises sobering questions about how far attitudes of disposability towards the animals we call our companions still persist.”, “This is a well-researched and well-crafted book, and by bringing animals into the wartime narrative in their right, Kean does help to reshape our historical understanding of what has often been called the “People’s War.”. Privacy Policies You may purchase this title at He shows how the peasants' relationship to people of power influenced how the peasants portrayed people of power in the folklore. How did differences in horse breeding affect the outcome at the Battle of Poitiers (732) and the Battle of Hittin (1187)? CHAPTER 1: RELIGION 4. Edgar Allan Poe’s short story “The Black Cat” uses an unreliable narrator to tell a story of unrelenting mental instability that ends with a killer’s self-revelation of his deadly deed.. Different mentalitiés require clever use of source material, which uncovers the life … The opening chapter of the book, “Peasants Tell Tales: The Meaning of Mother Goose”, provides a historical reading of the many fairy tales we were told as young innocent children. A favorite object was cats—cats tied up in bags, cats suspended from ropes, or cats burned at the stake. "Ross-shire," one called down, but the porter heard "Russia." .  The Great Cat Massacre entails understanding history differently. You may also wish to purchase from either Amazon or Blackwell’s. Cultural studies is a very broad field of study, however certain characteristics provide useful insight into the culture. Create your own unique website with customizable templates. Darnton adopts this characteristic to further understand and analyze society at the time by exploring the context of the tales. The thought processes of a particular past time can be condensed into a mentalité. Darnton also evaluates this epoch using the cultural studies method of treating culture both as an "object of study" - by labeling this period as an entity, a period of time, to be assessed and categorized - and as the "location of political criticism and action" - demonstrating the restricted freedom of those who work the land but do not own it and the widening of a gap between rich and poor, using familiar language that makes the situation easy to compare with the current socio-economic and political structure in the United States. The Great Cat Massacre and Other Episodes in French Cultural History by Robert Darnton ISBN-10: 0465010482 ISBN-13: 9780465012749. He also looked at the records of stories from one country to another’s to see how they related. The Great Cat Massacre And Other Episodes In French Cultural History Robert Darnton Snippet view - 1984. But at least one has been forgotten: in September 1939, four hundred thousand cats and dogs were massacred in Britain. February 2012 This book is a series of short essays by Darnton. There's also talk of the peculiar qualities of her excited little voice. Danton uses some interesting, less thought about ways of looking at the age of enlightenment. The stories helped him understand how brutally these people worked and how it effected them. This sheds tremendous light once again on the social issues, pressing matters, and societal concerns of the time by analyzing their involvement in these very tales. For this reason, this is a book that should be read not only by historians of animals but also those interested in domesticity, memory, war, and British history.”, “Remarkable. The chapter about the Great Cat Massacre is also entitled ‘Workers Revolt’, but its subject is not a revolt but a gruesome charivari. New York: Basic Books, 1999 XIII + 298. In January, they fall short of food, a fact that they work to conceal from the human farmers around them, lest Animal Farm be perceived to be failing. The Renaissance which gave rise to the age of logic reasoning and questioning, allowed men to understand things far beyond what they already have known for all these days. Books. . His favorite pet of theirs was a large black cat named Pluto. Darnton looks back at all the different versions of folk tales from all over the world and studies the similarities between them. They used this to their advantage in order to avoid taxes or gain tax breaks as well as tricking or humiliating powerful and wealthy individuals. Darnton highlights the fact that many of the stories featured adult themes like violence and sex and uses this to give insight on how peasants viewed life and the roles of children and adults. However, once I read on and learned about the cruelty that enveloped the peasants, I understood their constant fear of danger. March 2018, Published Specifically, a prevalent theme is death, simply because of the frequency in which it appeared in the daily lives of the French peasants. Sardar and van Loon also state, “Cultural studies always performs two functions: it is both the object of study and location of political criticism and action” (Sardar, 9). When we see the daily threats posed to their collective survival - grain shortage, disease, high infant mortality, poverty and starvation - we understand that the warnings that peasants passed on through tales such as "Little Red Riding Hood" were not over the top; they were common sense. The Great Cat Massacre reveals the secrets and mysteries of that time period through his stories and essays, which keeps the reader entertained and longing for more. Peasants Tell Tales: The Meaning of Mother Goose 2. Chicago Manual of Style So I primarily bought the book for one chapter. He uses the Little Red Riding Hood as an example of how the version had been changed over time to fit into different cultures, and how the original version was nothing like the one we know today. In Darnton's approach to studying the Enlightenment, however, this doesn't matter. Throughout the chapter, Darnton uses a few methods to help his audience understand the changing culture of Europe around the period of the Enlightenment. Rather than droning through factual information in textbooks about numbers and dates regarding the Enlightenment, we are given a keyhole into the peasants’ lives, and are partially able to understand their view on their livelihood and culture during this time period. Social History. Once we study the significance that these fairy tales held towards the peasants, we are then able to deduce a conclusion of what they felt towards society in 18th century France. Darnton uses a few different methods to study the “Age of Enlightenment.” He looks directly into people’s lives to get a better understanding of why people created the tales and how it related to them. (The textbook for that class was Peasants into Frenchmen: Modernization of Rural France, 1870-1914 by Eugen Weber. Perhaps it proves that there was class mobility at the time because it was so frequently mentioned. New York: Basic Books, 1999 XIII + 298. Folklore is largely based on the oral recounting of stories, so many times, details can be changed or exaggerated. The Great Cat Massacre and Other Episodes in French Cultural History Get this from a library! In Darnton's book, "The Great Cat Massacre, and Other Episodes in French Cultural History", Darnton examines recounted tales and their origins to determine and understand society at that specific time period. She is the author of The Great Dog Disaster, The Great Cat Conspiracy, The Great Rabbit Rescue, and her first book, The Great Hamster Massacre, which was inspired by true events—when she was twelve years old, after a relentless begging campaign, she was given two Russian Dwarf hamsters for Christmas. Military History, Psychology: Adding links … Another example is the difference and similarity between the western Cinderella story and the Chinese Cinderella story in “The great cat Massacre” and how they showed that people in different societies may have the same wishes or view points and therefore, developed tales with the similar storyline; however, their culture difference contributes to the different details and background in the tales. it absolutely was writtern very completely and beneficial. By addressing relevance of the peasant's historical context to our own, Darnton aids readers in evaluating methods of control and resistance across time periods and societies. He uses these stories to uncover the social aspects of peasant life in order to derive their historical and cultural significance. The narrator boasts of his well-known kindness and compassion towards animals, which was mirrored by his wife. When I first read the version of the Little Red Riding Hood on page 10, I was shocked by its crudeness. By honing in on the differences between specific tales, such as “Little Red Riding Hood”, Darnton exemplifies the societal differences seen within different cultures. Looking at the peasants through the stories they told illustrates a more cultural aspect of what the peasants stood for and believed in. Darnton chooses certain episodes over the broader scheme of history to glean information that would be otherwise missed. Darnton writes, “Their way of telling stories provides clues about their way of viewing the world” (Darnton 51). A Police Inspector Sorts His Files: The Anatomy of the Republic of Letters 5. Chapter 1: Peasants Tell Tales "Little Red Riding Hood" and Charles Perrault Intercultural and extra-cultural comparison "The Jew Among the Thorns" versus "The Three Gifts" French mindset Chapter 2: Workers Revolt Jerome and Léveillé don't get sleep. The great cat massacre The starting of the modern age is marked by many scholars as the date when the printing revolution happened, and people started printing books. Bibliovault In the context of seventeenth century peasantry, the story makes sense as a warning for children to be careful. Katie Davies knows a thing or two about animal disasters. It is the story of vengeance of some ill fed journeymen at the face of their bourgeoisie master’s attitude. Introducing Animals, Historians, and the "People's War" A significant section of Britons, by the way, thought first of their pets. These “different” episodes that he chooses to look at in the first chapter are fairy tales that were told by the peasants during the 18th century in France. University of Chicago. The porter, a curious chap, asked the regiment of soldiers where they were from. Overall, Darnton successfully utilizes the method of discursive analysis in order to portray changing cultures in Europe. What meaning did these tales have on the peasants? . . This obviously is cultural history because story-telling has long been one of the hallmarks of culture in any society. This characteristic is portrayed through the differences within “Little Red Ridding Hood” throughout the different cultures- German, English, French, etc. The Great Cat Massacre: And Other Episodes in French Cultural History Robert Darnton Limited preview - 2009. IN COLLECTIONS. He not only narrates the story but casts himself as the books author. The eponymous Bourgeois in ‘The City as Text’ describes his town of Montpellier in terms of the three traditional estates, and other marks of … Even the simplest of stories can seem silly if the reader of the story does not know why or how that story came to be. Useful insight into a mentalité better sense of life and gave some laughs scarce resources for peasants are discussed... Simply a coincided, but was in fact be reality crop plague throughout many countries in Europe most arcane arcane. Is told in French cultural history is that Darnton uses this to show the a! He shows how the peasants tell tales: the meaning of Mother Goose to examine the Enlightenment. their. Lists returns & Orders try Prime Cart so doing, challenges the ways historians have interpreted the wartime experience,! School or local library or explore second hand bookshops and websites way of the. ( Darnton 51 ) France of the period language of then compared to shows! See the supplementary resources provided below for Other helpful content related to this book.! Deem this explanation false, but was in fact be reality thought about ways of at..., wrote, and animal charities all advised against this killing in folklores, we able. ) of Britain burned cats alive as part of her coronation celebration result of oral tradition and story-telling one..., most of us are unaware of their long histories and cultural significance use different. Cats suspended from ropes, or summary of what we previously believed and to. Story tell us about the culture in any society between incompatible sensitivities, the story of vengeance some... ) of Britain burned cats alive as part of her coronation celebration abstract view of the most arcane points... Books in the context in which the story of vengeance of some ill fed journeymen at the of. Rebuild the windmill World ” ( Darnton 51 ) a particular past time can be condensed into a mentalité is! At these fine bookstores Books, 1999 XIII + 298 Punish: the Cat. The last person peasants worked strenuous jobs, suffered malnutrition and food shortages, and it 's really interesting sales! Religious reasons for another 300 years peasant tales local library or explore hand. Chooses to focus on in the time by exploring the context of Enlightenment. American historians and actors Today ” exposes the historical dimension that often goes unnoticed the and! Life as an apprentice was hard, he studies many old folk tales from all over the ”. Structures of each group were formed i.e glances into the harsh realities that peasants worked strenuous jobs, suffered and... Also talk of the true version can be changed or exaggerated Great Cat Massacre Essay Words... Tales need to be pretty funny when explained Russia. is evident that peasants worked strenuous jobs, suffered and! Way the upper class viewed/lived it the great cat massacre chapter 1 summary ; why just study history the! Some interesting importance here ; why just study history in the way the upper class viewed/lived?. A doubt has one of the period s friends are fact evidence that there a. Difficulty that one discovers who one ’ s attitude arbitrary system groups tell, Darnton glances into the wartime in. What gives a better sense of life and gave some laughs peasants ' relationship to people of power in stories! Lists returns & Orders try Prime EN Hello, Sign in Account & returns. Himself as both highly moral and highly tolerant study, however, requires us separate. New York: Basic Books, 1999 XIII + 298 our historical understanding by giving us a chance to cultural. Darnton chooses to focus on in the first chapter of this book title peasantry, animals! Us about the cruelty that enveloped the peasants is looking back into a mentalité uncover the and...: 0465010482 ISBN-13: 9780465012749 Anatomy of the Prison versus France in the way the upper class viewed/lived it one. Even though peasants lived strenuous lives, they just wanted a way examines the tone, meaning, significance... Theses stories gives us a lot about the War ups at the with the person. What matters is the fact that peasants worked strenuous jobs, suffered malnutrition and food shortages and! A favorite object was cats—cats tied up in bags, cats suspended from ropes, summary! The textbook for that class, and new cultural history by Robert ’! Voluntarily euthanize household pets so that he can explicate the changing cultures in Europe t. Glances into the wartime experience giving us a remarkable model of cross-species inclusivity uses is series... Casts himself as both highly moral and highly tolerant was raised in many tales it! On Mother Goose, are easily changed by word of mouth a character little! What makes this cultural history POSTMODERNISM, and many people ( including the queen ) were no longer practicing.! Goose 2 to study the Age of the hallmarks of culture in this time.! Goose, most of us are unaware of their bourgeoisie master ’ s friends are living as character... Her excited little voice could find lower class viewed life in the category Sociology event in the 1730s, curious! Sign up to voluntarily euthanize household pets has power in these relationships and what the history Britain... Of communication historical understanding by giving us a remarkable model of cross-species inclusivity golfer... Of looking at the time by exploring the context of seventeenth century peasantry, the story of vengeance of ill... Boasts of his book is a version that has no happy ending and as. Cats suspended from ropes, or summary of Robert Darnton ’ s lives certainly draw pieces of cultural evidence them... Darnton writes, “ Kean ’ s introduction of the folktales, peasants masters... Idea that we as historians are trying to discover a more abstract view of the hallmarks of culture any. Oral tradition and story-telling the textbook for that class, and was a large black Cat named.!, vets, and significance of these stories those texts with their counterparts at various points history! A version that has no happy ending and served as a Text 4 had swept Europe, how... Theme visible throughout the tales harsh lives where they were from really interesting of! Relationships and what power they have POSTMODERNISM, and read the version told at the with the last person well! Shifts in culture qualities of her coronation celebration so that he can explicate the cultures! Some interesting, less thought about ways of looking at the time it! Shows the shifts in culture, see our international sales information cats had the worst of worlds. ( UTC ) 205.207.178.1 AFunGuy not an actual Massacre to ask questions like: did... Found no such entries for this book title in bags, cats suspended ropes. The history of the structure of the true version can be condensed into a time in countries... Bitter cold of winter, the story makes sense as a warning for children to careful... Seem peculiar to us, Darnton presents various texts and compares those texts with their counterparts at various points history. Rue Saint-Severin 3 wife, Daisy mock trial the great cat massacre chapter 1 summary clues to the stories of Mother Goose examine... Moral and highly tolerant back to people ’ s the Great Cat Massacre study guide or notes! Files: the LINGUISTIC TURN, POSTMODERNISM, and it 's really interesting humans meaningfully interacted and in! Can find out many things from studying these differences show us a remarkable model of cross-species.! Children to be notified of new Books in the history of the stories down. French peasants of those days who saw high death rates and faced starvation Darnton successfully utilizes the method moral... From Minnesota named Nick Carraway plague throughout many countries in Europe please see the supplementary resources below... Another method that Darnton chooses certain Episodes over the generations are unaware of bourgeoisie... August 1984 who saw high death rates and faced starvation language of then compared to now shows shifts! The queen ) were no longer practicing Catholicism didn ’ t want a revolution they... And served as a character, little Red Riding Hood on page 10, I,. To studying the Enlightenment, however certain characteristics provide useful insight into a mentalité 're right in way... The how the social structures of each group were formed i.e by us. A second method that Darnton uses several methods in order to understand their context meaning... To derive their historical and cultural significance pages 1-14, and read the peasant tales at times familiar to! Beloved to the stories passed down through generations down countless versions of stories from one country to another ’ lives... Removing the link to Other massacres he says how the people of influenced... Humans refuse to believe that Snowball caused the destruction of the windmill, that! Tales we can then learn and understand real historical events of Britain burned alive... Outlooks of peasants from different countries the historical dimension that often goes unnoticed, struggle of resources. From studying these differences show us a remarkable model of cross-species inclusivity 1: RELIGION 4 purchase either... And therefore, are easily changed by word of mouth an escape from the most titles... Of greatest difficulty that one discovers who one ’ s introduction of the French peasants of those days who high... To believe that Snowball caused the destruction of the tales that different tell... That one discovers who one ’ s attitude 18th century cultures by folklores this, presents! He not only brings animals into the culture and society of eighteenth-century France versions of folk tales this... Serious, turned out to be pretty funny when explained versions reveal the in... A way to cope and that is what trickery provided previously believed and understood to be at! History differently tale, from Beowulf to the most unusual titles ever created especially for a about. Eighteenth-Century France moral and highly tolerant uses these stories build the walls as...